Monday, 3 October 2016

S37



•S37(1) of General Law Amendment Act 62 of 1955 provides


1)Any person who in any manner, otherwise than a public sale, acquires or receives into his or her possession from any other person stole goods other than stock or produce as defined in S13 of the stock Theft Act,1959, without reasonable cause for believing at the time of such acquisition or receipt that such goods are the property of the person from whom he or she receives them or that such a person has been duly authorized by the owner thereof o deal with or dispose of them, shall be guilty of an offence and liable on conviction to the penalties which may be imposed on conviction of receiving stolen property knowing it to have been stolen except insofar as the imposition of any such penalty may be compulsory.


2)In the absence of evidence to the contrary which raises a reasonable doubt, prof of such possession shall be sufficient of the absence of reasonable cause.

Elements


•Possession: the type of possession is the same as that of S36


•A reasonable cause for believing: the requirement that a person must have reasonable cause for believing that he received the goods from the owner or an unauthorized person is objectively determined. The belief must exist at the time that a person receives the goods…. S v Manamela


ROBBERY
X commits robbery by stealing Y’s property through the unlawful and intentional use of violence, or threats of violence to induce Y to submit to the theft.


Elements


•Theft


•Actual or threatened violence,  linked to the theft


•An intention to acquire the property


• by means of violence


•Unlawfulness


Study:


•Ex parte Minister of Justice: in re R v Gesa; R v de Jongh


Pg 519 paragraph7


üThis is a common law crime


üIt’s an aggravated form of theft


üYou will notice that all the elements of theft apply to that of robbery


üThis is why the crime f theft is a competent verdict of robbery


In so far as violence is concerned it must be directed to Y. it may be slight and Y doesn’t need to be injured


Violence can also be committed even though there is no real violence directed at Y


Causal link between violence and the taking(theft)…
üThere must be a link between the violence or the threat of violence and the taking (theft) of the property
üThe property must be obtained by X as a result of the violence or threat of violence
üThere is a premise that violence must precede the taking… please note that sometimes it follows the completion of the taking.
üE.g. X robs Y, X must use violence against Y to overcome Y’s resistance when taking the property
Case law… bag snatching Sithole 1981, Mofokeng 1982
Shop robbery through threatening phone calls Pachai 1962

Robbery with aggravating circumstances!


What constitutes aggravating circumstances?


ü in terms of S1 of the Criminal Procedure Act it comprises of the following


•Use of firearm or any dangerous weapon


•The infliction of grievous bodily harm


•A threat to inflict grievous bodily harm


Minimum sentence 15yrs first offender, 2nd offender 20- 25yrs








Friday, 23 September 2016

CRIMES AGAINST THE DIGNITY AND REPUTATION



Crimen iniuria


 


•Definition: is the unlawful, intentional and serious infringement of the dignity or privacy of another.


•What is the difference between crimen iniuria and criminal defamation?

CRIMEN INIURIA


1.Violations of a person’s dignity and privacy = punishable


2.  2 parties involved




CRIMINAL DEFEMATION


1. Violations of a person’s good name or reputation is punishable (publication does not have to be in print – it must come to the attention of people other than Y)





2. 3 parties involved

Crimen inuria: In General





• Dignity = self-respect, mental tranquillity


•Privacy can be infringed without Y being aware of the infringement e.g. X watches Y undressing


•Can lead to a civil claim and criminal prosecution


•Subjective and objective elements of infringement:

Subjective

•With the infringement of dignity Y must be aware of X’s offending behaviour and feel degraded or humiliated by it (differs from the rule for privacy i.e. need not be aware of X’s conduct)





•Exception: children/mentally disabled  


Objective
X’s conduct must offend at least the feelings of a reasonable person i.e. not a hypersensitive person




•The infringement must be serious


•Grounds of justification are consent, necessity, official capacity


FACTORS


•Y’s public standing


•Relationship between parties


•Sexual impropriety


•Nature of act


•Gender


•Publicity


•Persistence


•Age



Elements


•The infringement of dignity or privacy of another


•Which is serious


•Unlawfulness and


• intention


KINDLY REFER TO SNYMAN FOR CASE LAW THERE ARE WAY TOO MANY…

CRIMINAL DEFAMATION




Definition: Is the unlawful and intentional publication of matter which concerns another which tends to seriously injure his reputation.


ELEMENTS


•The publication


•Of a defamatory allegation concerning another which is


•Serious


•unlawfully


•intentionally
CRIME AGAINST FREEDOM OF MOVEMENT: KIDNAPPING




•Definition: Unlawful and intentional depriving of a person of his or her freedom of movement and if such a person is a child, the custodians of their control over the child.


•Elements:


a)Deprivation


b)A person’s freedom of movement ( or parental control in the case of a child) which takes place


c)Unlawfully and


d)Intentionally




Please note: the crime can be committed in respect of a child, woman or man. Duration of deprivation is usually irrelevant. See foot note 21  page 481case law e.g. Blanche  etc.


•Forcible removal is not a requirement. Removal may also be effected by cunning see relevant case on page 481
CRIMES AGAINST PROPERTY
THEFT





Definition: Theft is the unlawful, intentional appropriation of movable, corporeal property which:


(1)Belongs to, and is in the possession of another


(2)Belongs to another but is in the perpetrator’s own possession, or


(3)Belongs to the perpetrator but is in another’s possession and such other person has a right to possess it which legally prevails against the perpetrator’s own right of possession





•Provided that the intention to appropriate the property includes an intention permanently to deprive the person entitled to the possession of the property, of such property

•X commits theft by unlawfully and intentionally taking  the property of Y, which is capable of being stolen, without Y’s consent and appropriating it to himself, X.


•Elements


a)Unlawfulness


b)Intent


c)Appropriation


d)The property must be capable of being stolen.

•CAN


•ELECTRICITY


•BE


•STOLEN???

•S v Mintoor 1996 (1) SACR 514 (c) the court considered the scope and content of the common law crime of theft and held that, because of its nature, electricity cannot be stolen for purposes of common law theft.


•This decision was criticised and ultimately not followed.




•S V Ndebele and others, the cort again examined the true nature of electricity and came to a conclusion that it is indeed something that can be stolen.


NOTE


The common law crime of theft continues to be committed for as long as the thief remains in possession of the stolen property. This has two consequences.

1.A person may be convicted of theft if he steals property outside the jurisdiction of a court on the basis that he is found in possession of the stolen property within the  court’s jurisdiction.


2.A person who assists a thief still in possession of the stolen property after its removal is not an accessory after the fact. He is guilty of the theft since it is a continuing crime

FORMS OF THEFT




•Removal of property: X commits this form of theft if he removes Y’s property, which is in Y’s (or somebody else) possession and appropriates it.


•Embezzlement: X commits this form of theft if he appropriates Y’s property which is already in X’s possession


•Arrogation of possession:  X commits this form of theft if he takes his own property from the possession of Y, who has the right to its possession which prevails against the owner. E.g. a pledge.


Example : Y wishes to borrow money from X. Y gives X his watch as a guarantee to pay…..

Is temporary deprivation of property theft?





•No! Furtum usus is not a form of theft (but section 1 of Act 50 of 1956 creates an offence where property is unlawfully removed for temporary use). There must be an intention to permanently deprive the owner of her property (Sibiya case)
Q




•X is a doctor who takes possession of four microscopes belonging to the Botswana government without their consent. He intends to return the microscopes to them if they will drop certain charges against him. Explain whether X commits theft with regard to the general requirements of liability for theft.


Did you answer this question correctly
•Answer: Theft includes the unlawful and intentional appropriation of moveable corporeal property which belongs to another but which is in the perpetrators own possession (embezzlement)(1). Must be an act of appropriation where the lawful owner is deprived of the property(1) and the rights of an owner are exercised in respect of the property(1). Unlawfulness means the owner must not consent and there must be no grounds of justification (1). There must be the intention to permanently deprive the owner of his or her property. Furtum usus is no longer a form of theft ito Sibiya.(1) After Sibiya the legislature created an offence ito section 1 of Act 50 of 1956 which punishes the unlawful removal of another’s property for temporary use.(1) This case above in the problem question is an exception to the rule in section 1 Act 50 of 1956 (Van Coller). X is not guilty as lacks the intention to deprive the owner of the full benefit of the ownership (1) -









de
•1. depriving the lawful owner of her propertpriving the lawful owner of her property