Tuesday, 18 July 2017


PARTICIPATION AND ACCESSORY AFTER THE FACT


1.Participants

ØPerpetrators

ØAccomplices



2. Non participants

ØAccessories after the fact

What is a participant?

•Anyone who FURTHERS the commission of the crime.

•A non-participant does not further the commission of the crime e.g.. accessory after the fact (we will touch on this later)

Perpetrator

A person is a perpetrator if

1) his conduct, the circumstances in which it takes place and the culpability with which it is carried out are such that he satisfies all the requirements for liability contained in the definition of the offence;

OR

2) if, although his own conduct does not comply with that required in the definition of the crime, he acted together with one or more persons and the conduct required for a conviction is imputed to him by virtue of the principles relating to the doctrine of common purpose.

Difference between direct/ indirect perpetrator

Irrelevant for purposes of determining liability

•Direct: own hands to commit a crime.

•Indirect: uses someone else to commit a crime.

•Co-perpetrator: is a perpetrator where several persons commit the crime together.

Definition of an accomplice



A person is an accomplice if:

•Although he does not comply with all the requirements for liability set out in the definition of the crime, and

•Although the conduct required for a conviction is not imputed to him in terms of the doctrine of common purpose, he engages in conduct whereby he furthers the commission of the crime by someone else.

Doctrine of common purpose

•If two or more people, having a common purpose to commit a crime, act together in order to achieve that purpose, the acts of each of them in the execution of such a purpose are imputed to the others.

Proof of common purpose?
üPrior agreement
üActive association and participation in a common criminal design
ØCases!!! You must know in detail:
•Thebus
•Safatsa
•Mgedezi
•Molimi

Mgedezi



•If no proof of a previous agreement between the perpetrators, the following requirements must be met to be found guilty based on common purpose:

1.Must have been present at the scene of the crime (not a passive spectator).

2.Must have been aware of the assault on Y.

3.He must have intended to make common cause with others

4.He must have performed an act of association.

5.He must have had the intention to kill or to contribute to the death.

•When can active association result in liability?

üY must still be alive and be at a stage before the mortal wound is inflicted (Motaung)

üLiability based on active association has been declared constitutional (Thebus)



What if the conduct differs from the conduct in the initial mandate?

üMolimi: may not be imputed unless each of the latter knew or foresaw the possibility that it might be committed and reconciled themselves to that possibility.

Disassociation/ withdrawal from common purpose

1.There must be a clear and unambiguous intention to withdraw.

2.X must perform a positive act of withdrawal.

3.The type of act required for an effective withdrawal depends upon a number of circumstances.

4.The withdrawal must take place before the events have reached the commencement of the execution.

5.The withdrawal must be voluntary.

Joiner-in (Motaung)

•A joiner-in associates himself with another’s common purpose at a stage when the lethal wound has already been inflicted.

1.The injury must not hasten X’s death.

2.The victim must still be alive.

3.There must not be a previous conspiracy or common purpose.
Accessory nature
 
•There must be a perpetrator in order to be found guilty of this crime
•Can one be an accomplice to murder?
Williams case and criticism by Snyman
•i.e can you actually further a victim’s death without also causing it ?
•See also Safatsa – common purpose and co-perpetrators
Accessories after the fact
NB Is not a participant. Why?
üShe does not further the crime
üOnly in the picture AFTER the crime is committed and helps the perpetrator to evade liability

What is the definition of an accessory after the fact?
•
•A person is an accessory after the fact to the commission of a crime if, after the commission of the crime, she unlawfully and intentionally engages in conduct intended to enable the perpetrator of or accomplice to the crime to evade liability for her crime, or to facilitate such a person’s evasion of liability

Did you get the definition correct?
Can you be an accessory to a crime committed by yourself?
In principle no!
There has to be a perpetrator as it is an accessory crime.

üException: See Gani and Jonathan cases
In summaryL!
 
PERPETRATOR:
1.those who personally commit the crime either acting alone or with other persons
2.Those that get an innocent person or agent to commit on their behalf
3.Those who form a common purpose to commit a crime with someone else who actually executes the crime X keeps watch while Y steals
ACCOMPLICES:
Before it used to be the accessory before the fact but this fell away
üIf he lawfully and intentionally furthers a crime committed by somebody by assisting him/ by facilitating the crime/encouraging it!!!! J
SELF ASSESMENT QUESTION
 
A is the leader of a drug syndicate. Y, a member, decides to sever his ties with the syndicate, and to join another syndicate. Avenging the defection, A cuts Y’s throat. Mortally wounded, Y collapses. B, who previously had supplied drugs to Y, appears on the scene and, furious because Y owes him money, shoots Y in the stomach.
 (B had not agreed beforehand with A to kill Y.) The bullet wound does not hasten Y’s death. Y dies as a result of the wound to his throat. A needs help to get rid of the corpse. For this purpose he calls in the aid of C, who had agreed before the murder to help A to get rid of the corpse, and D who had no such agreement with A. Together they drag the body to a secluded beach and dump the body in the ocean.
Briefly discuss:

a) the criminal liability of B, referring to authority   (4)
b)the criminal liability of C   (2)
c) the criminal liability of D   (2)
ANSWER
 
a) B is a joiner-in, because:
(1) the bullet wound he inflicted on Y did not hasten Y’s death;
(2) Y was still alive at the time;
(3) there was no previous conspiracy to murder (common purpose).

B can be convicted of attempted murder, and not murder (Motaung 1990 (4) SA 485 (A)), because to hold B liable for murder in these circumstances would amount to holding him responsible ex post facto for his acts.
•
b)  Since C agreed prior to the commission of the crime to render assistance, he is regarded as a perpetrator since his conduct, culpability and personal qualities accord with the definition of murder. (C can also according to the Williams case be an accomplice to murder.)
c)  D is an accessory after the fact. D unlawfully and intentionally engaged after the commission of the crime in conduct that is intended to enable the perpetrator or accomplice to evade liability for the crime, or to facilitate such a person’s evasion of liability.