Monday, 3 October 2016

S37



•S37(1) of General Law Amendment Act 62 of 1955 provides


1)Any person who in any manner, otherwise than a public sale, acquires or receives into his or her possession from any other person stole goods other than stock or produce as defined in S13 of the stock Theft Act,1959, without reasonable cause for believing at the time of such acquisition or receipt that such goods are the property of the person from whom he or she receives them or that such a person has been duly authorized by the owner thereof o deal with or dispose of them, shall be guilty of an offence and liable on conviction to the penalties which may be imposed on conviction of receiving stolen property knowing it to have been stolen except insofar as the imposition of any such penalty may be compulsory.


2)In the absence of evidence to the contrary which raises a reasonable doubt, prof of such possession shall be sufficient of the absence of reasonable cause.

Elements


•Possession: the type of possession is the same as that of S36


•A reasonable cause for believing: the requirement that a person must have reasonable cause for believing that he received the goods from the owner or an unauthorized person is objectively determined. The belief must exist at the time that a person receives the goods…. S v Manamela


ROBBERY
X commits robbery by stealing Y’s property through the unlawful and intentional use of violence, or threats of violence to induce Y to submit to the theft.


Elements


•Theft


•Actual or threatened violence,  linked to the theft


•An intention to acquire the property


• by means of violence


•Unlawfulness


Study:


•Ex parte Minister of Justice: in re R v Gesa; R v de Jongh


Pg 519 paragraph7


üThis is a common law crime


üIt’s an aggravated form of theft


üYou will notice that all the elements of theft apply to that of robbery


üThis is why the crime f theft is a competent verdict of robbery


In so far as violence is concerned it must be directed to Y. it may be slight and Y doesn’t need to be injured


Violence can also be committed even though there is no real violence directed at Y


Causal link between violence and the taking(theft)…
üThere must be a link between the violence or the threat of violence and the taking (theft) of the property
üThe property must be obtained by X as a result of the violence or threat of violence
üThere is a premise that violence must precede the taking… please note that sometimes it follows the completion of the taking.
üE.g. X robs Y, X must use violence against Y to overcome Y’s resistance when taking the property
Case law… bag snatching Sithole 1981, Mofokeng 1982
Shop robbery through threatening phone calls Pachai 1962

Robbery with aggravating circumstances!


What constitutes aggravating circumstances?


ü in terms of S1 of the Criminal Procedure Act it comprises of the following


•Use of firearm or any dangerous weapon


•The infliction of grievous bodily harm


•A threat to inflict grievous bodily harm


Minimum sentence 15yrs first offender, 2nd offender 20- 25yrs