Tuesday, 8 August 2017

….pending cases


This form of contempt is often described as a violation of the so-called sub judice rule. This means that no one should publish anything about a pending case or a comment on case where the publication or commentary is potentially prejudicial to the outcome of the case.

Of course, newspapers report about pending cases all the time, but the tone and aim of the reporting must be factual, rather than a form of comment which would be prejudicial. Note that this is in conflict with S16 (1) of the 96 constitution.

Remember we need to protect the dignity and integrity of the legal process and also the rights of the accused which are to be protected by the court.
 
Interference with witness or the presiding officer.


•It is a crime to improperly influence or attempt to influence a judge, magistrate, an assessor, witnesses, witnesses, complainant e.t.c

•Yes it does overlap with the crime of corruption.
 
Failure to appear in court


•If a person is summoned to appear in court but fails to do so intentionally and for no good reason. That individual will be prosecuted for contempt of court (ex facie curiae)



Scandalising the court S v Mamabolo 2001

Please make time to read on this. It will be discussed on the next occasion. Tell me your views based on what you have read!
elements


(a) (i) violation of the dignity

     (ii) the publication of information or commentary concerning   a pending judicial proceeding

(b) the administration of justice by the courts

(c) unlawfulness and

(d) intention
PERJURY AND RELATED CRIMES


Making a false statement under oath or affirmation in the course of a judicial proceeding is a crime under South African common law. The common law is supplemented by a statutory crime, namely making conflicting statements under different oaths (contravention of S319 (3) Act 56 of 1955). It is also a crime to make a false statement in an affidavit.



The rationale for the criminalisation of these offences is that witnesses should always tell the truth and nothing but the truth in courts or in affidavits. Without this the system will not be able to function effectively and with integrity.

Elements (a) making of a declaration (b) which is false (c) under oath or in a form equivalent to an oath (d) in the course of judicial proceeding (e) unlawfulness (f) intention
Common law perjury


This crime consists in the unlawful and international making of a false statement in the course of a judicial proceeding by a person who has taken the oath or made an affirmation before, or who has been admonition by, somebody competent to administer or accept the oath.

•False statements: means verbal or in writing in a form of an affidavit. Although the point has not been authoritavely decided in South Africa, it seems that the statement must be ‘objectively false’.

This means that a witness who intends(subjectively) to tell lie in court, but the statement in actual fact turns out to be true, commits not perjury but a crime of attempted perjury, or defeating or obstructing the course of justice.
… continue


•The state does not need to prove that the false statement is material to any issue to be decided by court.

•The case of perjury can only be committed in the course of a judicial proceeding (criminal or civil). Note that affidavits made to the police in  the context of an investigation do not qualify as ‘statements made in the course of judicial proceedings’

•Oath, affirmation or admonition: this requirement implies that any statements by a legal representative in court, as part of legal argument (in other words not testimony under oath)will be excluded from the ambit of the common-law crime perjury. It is important to note that witnesses must be sworn in, or the affirmation must be accepted by a court official who is competent.

•Intention: the accused must know (or at least foresee) the possibility that his statement maybe false. Thus dolus eventualis will be sufficient. It is also necessary to show that the accused knew that he was under oath(affirmation or admonition), and the relevant statement was made in the course of judicial proceedings.
MAKING CONFLICTING STATEMENTS UNDER DIFFERENT OATHS


•This kind of crime is in contravention of S 319 (3) of 1995 which provides: if a person ahs made any statement on oath whether orally or in writing, and he there after on another oath makes another statement as aforesaid, which is in conflict with such first- mentioned statements, he shall be guilty of an offence and may on a charge alleging that he made the two conflicting statements and upon proof of those two statements and without proof as to which of the said statements was false, be convicted of such offences and punished with the penalties prescribed by law for the crime of perjury, unless it is proved that when he made each statement he believed it to be true.

•unlike common law perjury, this statutory form of perjury does not require that the statements be made in the course of a judicial proceedings.

What state has to prove: is that the accused on two occasions made two conflicting statements under oath and that that the statements conflict each other. Mohamed 1951 1 SA 439 and

Mofokeng 1957 2 SA 162 (o)

What state has to prove: is that the accused on two occasions made two conflicting statements under oath and that that the statements conflict each other. Mohamed 1951 1 SA 439 and

Mofokeng 1957 2 SA 162 (o)
MAKING FALSE STATEMENTS IN AN AFFIDAVIT


•Contravention of S9 of Act 16 of 1963 of the Justices of the Peace & Commissioners of Oath Act provides that any person who in an affidavit, affirmation or take the declaration in question, has made a false statement knowing it to be false, commits an offence. This crime is completed when the false statement is made (in proceedings other than testimony under oath during court proceedings) the statutory requires mens rea in the form of intent.

•Case law s v Zuma 1995, S v Mbatha 1996, S v Theron 1968
OBSTRUCTING POLICE IN THE PERFOMANCE OF THEIR DUTIES


•Crimes against the administration of justice do not only involve the and the functioning of the courts but importantly and crucially also the work of the police.

•S 67 (1) of the SAPS Act provides that any person who resists or wilfully hinders or obstructs a police in the exercise of his powers or performance of his duties or functions, commits an offence. Interference with a police officer’s uniform or equipment also constitutes a criminal offence.

•Dolus eventualis is sufficient as where one foresees the possibility that it is a policeman he is obstructing but nevertheless continues with his conduct
DEFEATING OR OBSTRUCTING THE COURSE OF JUSTICE


•This crime consist of unlawfully and intentionally engaging in conduct that defeats the course or administration of justice.

•in S v Burger the court referred to the difference between ‘defeating’ and ‘obstructing’ the course of justice. To defeat the course of justice, the accused must in fact have defeated the course of justice (for instance where an innocent person has been convicted as the result of the actions of the accused) obstructing is something less: conduct that could lead to the end result of defeating the course of justice.

•Its important to note that these are not two distinct crimes. It is a single crime of defeating or obstructing the course of justice

•The accused conduct can take many forms for an example: influencing or trying to influence a witness, fabricating evidence, hampering the investigation of a crime scene and so on. Depending on facts and circumstances, such actions can overlap with crimes such as forgery, fraud, extortion and corruption

•Elements: (a) conduct (b) which amounts to defeating or obstructing (c) the course or administration of justice and which takes place (d) unlawfully and (e) intentionally
 
Discussion J


•Warning other motorists about speed traps: does this constitute obstruction of justice?

There are two seemingly conflicting judgements on this point. In S v Naidoo the court held that warning other motorists about the presence of a speed trap is to interfere with the due administration of justice. However in S v Perera the court held that the accused can only be guilty of obstructing of defeating the course of justice if he had reason to believe that the approaching vehicle exceeded the speed limit. If the accused driver is simply warning people in general about the presence of the speed, he is in effect warning other drivers to obey the law, which can hardly be a crime. Common sense approach in Perera is more like it!!!!J
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment