Where the accused intended to kill
another living human being but was unsuccessful (e.g. because he missed the
shot, the victim did not die from the wounds or because of inadequate means) he
can be found guilty of the separate crime of attempted murder.
As
pointed out above, where the accused thought he killed another living human
being (but the person was already dead) he can still be guilty of the crime of
attempted murder. The emphasis for criminal liability is thus on the subjective
state of mind of the accused.
S v Ngcamu and another 2011
CULPABLE
HOMICIDE
X commits culpable homicide where he
unlawfully and negligently causes the death of another human being.
elements
•Causing
death
•Causing
death of another person
•Unlawfulness
•Negligence:
it is this requirement that distinguishes culpable homicide from murder. The
test for negligence is an objective one, where the conduct of X is measured
against that of a reasonable person. This objective test should, of course
still be analysed contextually ( e.g. in the context of medical care or medical
negligence)
S v Van Heerden and another 2010 (1) SACR 529 ECP
INFANTICIDE
AND NEONATICIDE
INFANTICIDE…. Is the killing of a
new-born child.
Elements: are the same as those of
murder, as the intentional killing of an infant amounts to murder.
Note: it is recognised as separate crime
in South Africa. The latter is a statutory offence under the Child Care Act 74
of 1983
R v Adams 1903; S v Jokasi 1987
ADMINISTERING
POISON OR ANOTHER SUBSTANCE
Def: this crime consist in unlawfully and
intentionally administering poison or another substance to another person.
This crime overlaps with murder and
culpable homicide (Where Y dies as a result of the poison), attempted murder.
Its very rare that tis kind of crime is
prosecuted. It is commonly known as administering poison with intent to cause
grievous bodily harm. Please note this intent is not an essential element for
this crime.
According to Snyman: X
must have been aware of the fact that the substance he was dealing with was or
contained poison or some noxious substance, he must foresee the possibility
that someone might consume it. Refer page 453 foot note 39
Please note to administer it to an animal
will constitute to MI2P or attempt
EXPOSING
AN INFANT
page 454…..
CRIMES
AGAINST BODILY INTERGRITY
ASSAULT.
ASSAULT.
Definition: A person commits assault if he/ she
unlawfully and intentionally
1.applies force, directly or indirectly,
to the person of another, or
2.inspires a belief in another person
that force is immediately to be applied to her
GENERAL
1.The application of force can be direct (e.g.
punching someone) or indirect (e.g. setting a dog
on another person)
2.Includes the inspiring of fear in
another
3.Can attempted assault be committed?
Yes. E.g. if Y
does not understand the threat or is oblivious to it
4.What is assault with the intent to
commit grievous bodily harm? See Snyman 461 – 462!
5.What is assault with intent to commit
another crime? See Snyman 462
– 463!
Elements
•The
application
of force (or
the inspiring of a belief that force is to be applied);
•unlawfully; and
•intentionally.
i) Direct
The direct application of force is the
most common way in which the crime can be
committed, for example:
o X punches Y with her fist;
o kicks her;
o hits her with a stick; or
o throws a stone at her which strikes
her.
The fact that Y doesn’t feel much or any
physical pain is irrelevant. Thus X may commit the crime even if she only spits in Y's face or
trips her so that she stumbles
(ii) Indirect
The indirect application of force is any
non-direct act by which X infringes Y's physical
integrity, for example:
o X sets a vicious dog on Y;
o X snatches away a chair from under Y
just as she is about to sit on it, resulting in Y's
falling to the ground;
o X derails a train on which Y is
travelling; or
o X frightens a horse on which Y is
riding so that Y falls from the horse
Two examples from our case law of
convictions of assault where the application of force was indirect:
o In Marx X gave 3 glasses of wine to drink to each
of two children, 5 and 7 years old.
They became sick as a result and the
younger child couldn’t walk at all and was in a
semi-conscious condition. X was convicted
of assault The fact that the harm or
discomfort was internal rather that
external, was held to be irrelevant
No comments:
Post a Comment