•Contravention
of S9 of Act 16 of 1963 of the Justices of the Peace & Commissioners of
Oath Act provides that any person who in an affidavit, affirmation or take the
declaration in question, has made a false statement knowing it to be false,
commits an offence. This crime is completed when the false statement is made (in proceedings
other than testimony under oath during court proceedings) the statutory
requires mens
rea
in
the form of intent.
•Case
law s v Zuma
1995, S v Mbatha 1996,
S v Theron 1968
OBSTRUCTING
POLICE IN THE PERFOMANCE OF THEIR DUTIES
•Crimes
against the administration of justice do not only involve the and the
functioning of the courts but importantly and crucially also the work of the
police.
•S
67 (1) of the SAPS Act provides that any person who resists or wilfully hinders
or obstructs a police in the exercise of his powers or performance of his
duties or functions, commits an offence. Interference with a police officer’s
uniform or equipment also constitutes a criminal offence.
•Dolus eventualis
is
sufficient as where one foresees the possibility that it is a policeman he is
obstructing but nevertheless continues with his conduct
DEFEATING OR OBSTRUCTING THE COURSE OF
JUSTICE
•This
crime consist of unlawfully and intentionally
engaging in conduct that defeats the course or administration of
justice.
•in S
v Burger the court referred to the difference between ‘defeating’ and
‘obstructing’ the course of justice. To defeat the course of justice, the
accused must in fact have defeated the course of justice (for instance where an
innocent person has been convicted as the result of the actions of the accused)
obstructing is something less: conduct that could lead to the end result of
defeating the course of justice.
•Its
important to note that these are not two distinct crimes. It is a single crime
of defeating or obstructing the course of justice
•The
accused conduct can
take many forms for an example: influencing or trying to influence a witness,
fabricating evidence, hampering the investigation of a crime scene and so on.
Depending on facts and circumstances, such actions can overlap with crimes such
as forgery, fraud, extortion and corruption
•Elements: (a)
conduct (b) which amounts to defeating or obstructing (c) the course or
administration of justice and which takes place (d) unlawfully and
(e) intentionally
DiscussionJ
•Warning
other motorists about speed traps: does this constitute obstruction of justice?
There are two seemingly conflicting
judgements on this point. In S v Naidoo the court held that warning other
motorists about the presence of a speed trap is to interfere with the due
administration of justice. However in S v Perera the court held that the accused can only
be guilty of obstructing of defeating the course of justice if he had reason to
believe that the approaching vehicle exceeded the speed limit. If the accused
driver is simply warning people in general about the presence of the speed, he
is in effect warning other drivers to obey the law, which can hardly be a
crime. Common sense approach in Perera is more like it!!!!J
ESCAPING
FROM CUSTODY
There are three (3) groups of offences
relating to escaping from lawful custody namely:
1)The common-law crime of escaping: in
terms of common law it is a crime to escape from lawful detention. Even a
person who assist in the scape is equally liable.
2)Escaping and aiding escaping before
incarceration: S
51 of the criminal procedure Act 51 of 1977 deals with escaping after a lawful
arrest but before the accused is lodged/ out into a police cell…… this is a
criminal offence. Busuku
2006 1 SACR 96 (E). even
a person who assists commits an offence.
3)Offences created in correctional
Services Act relating to escaping: S117 provides that any prisoner who
escapes from custody commits a crime. Be it the prisoner collaborates with a
correctional official or conspires with any other person to leave prison
without lawful authority or under false pretences also commits a crime
Max 10 years impr
or a fineL
No comments:
Post a Comment