SEXUAL
CRIMES
Brief history: SA
criminal law has punished participants in sexual relations where they offended
the direct victim by a conduct or a family life. Further, the common law also
criminalised certain types of sexual relation because the impugned conduct was
considered to offend morality. Not all crimes of morality were concerned with
sexual relations.
Criminal punishment for immoral sexual
behaviour existed under Roman Law. The most serious which we call rape did not
have a name of its own. Please not note that even then sexual intercourse with
under-age girls was punishable, even if it did not involve any violence. Sexual
intercourse between unmarried persons was punishable as a crime of fornication.
Even adultery was punishable.
Gradually the focus on criminal law
deviated from fornication and adultery. Now we are going to look at or zoom
into THE CRIMINAL LAW(SEXUAL OFFENCES AND RELATED MATTERS) AMENDMENT ACT 32 OF
2007
INCEST
DEFINITION
S 12(1) of the sexual offences amendment
Act 32 of 2007 provides that: persons who may not lawfully marry
each other on account of consanguinity, affinity of an adoptive relationship
and who unlawfully and intentionally engage in an act of sexual penetration
with each other, are, despite their mutual consent to engage in such act, are
guilty of incest.
ELEMENTS
•Unlawfulness
•Intent
•An
act of sexual penetration
•An
act of sexual penetration between two people who may not lawfully marry each
other on account of consanguinity, affinity or adoptive relationship
Unlawfulness: S12(1)
makes it abundantly clear that the mutual consent of the parties plays no role
in absolving them of their liability. However proof of compulsion has been
accepted under the common law as excluding unlawfulness (R v Bourne 1952)
S56 (4) excludes the liability of the
accused if two requirements are met.
1.An accused may escape liability if, at
the time of the act of sexual penetration was committed, the accused was below
the age of 18years.
2.The other participant to the incestuous
sexual penetration, at the time that the act of sexual penetration was first
committed, exercised power and authority over the accused (who was younger than
18) or a relationship of trust existed between the accused and the other person
Intent: the
parties must intend to participate in conduct that involves sexual penetration
together with the knowledge that they are prohibited from inter-marrying or
participating in sexual penetration as a result of their relationship. (R V Pieterse
1923). If there is reasonable doubt resulting from a mistake of fact about the
prohibitive nature of the relationship the accused lacks mens
rea.
Sexual penetration: the
prohibited act consist of sexual penetration by any person with another person
without his/her consent. S1 of the act defines ‘sexual penetration as including
any act that causes penetration to any extent whatsoever by
a)The genital organs of one person into or
beyond the genital organs, anus or mouth of another person;
b)Any other part of the body of one person
or any object, including any part of the body of an animal, into or beyond the
genital organs or anus of another person or;
c)The genital organs of an animal, into or
beyond the mouth of another person.
Further, the act defines the term
‘genital organs’ as including the whole or part of the male of female genital
organs, as well as surgically constructed or reconstructed genital organs.
People who may not marry: the
new statutory crime of incest is a codification of the common-law crime of
incest. The general principles that relate to the prohibited degrees of
relation are congruent between the previous common-law crime and the new
statutory crime.
•S12
(2) provides that for the purpose of the statutory crime of incest:
a)The
prohibited degrees of consanguinity (blood relationship) are the following:
i.Ascendants and descendants in the direct
line or
ii.Collaterals, if either of them is related
to their common ancestor in their first degree of descent
b) The prohibited degrees of affinity are
relations by marriage in the ascending and descending line; and
c) An adoptive relationship is the
relationship of adoption as provided for in any other law.
BESTIALITY
Brief history:
Roman dutch law
punished all unnatural sexual conduct (including homosexuality and bestiality)
under the title venus monstra. Venus
monstra
constituted
‘gratification of sexual lust in a manner contrary to the order of nature.
Under English law the crimes of sodomy and bestiality were collectively called
buggery.
South African law eventually separated
the crimes of Sodomy, bestiality and unnatural offences. Bestiality (zoophilia) was
defined as unlawful and intentional sexual relations by a person with an
animal. Proof of penetration was required but not proof of semen emission. The
provisions of the common-law crime of bestiality have been repealed and
replaced by the provisions of Section 68 (1)(b) of the Criminal Law (Sexual
Offences and Related Matters) Amendment Act 32 of 2007.
definition
S 13 provides that: A person ‘A’ who
unlawfully and intentionally commits an act
1)Which causes penetration to any extent
whatsoever by the genital organs of
a)A into or beyond the mouth, genital
organs or anus of an animal, or
b)An animal into or beyond the mouth,
genital organs or anus of A, or
2) of
masturbation of an animal, unless such act is committed for scientific reasons
of breeding purposes, or of masturbation with an animal, is guilty of the
offence of bestiality.
•Unlawfulness
•Intent
•An
act the causes penetration by genital organs or masturbation of an animal
•An
act by a person with an animal
Please note: X may be either a male or a
female, and the animal may likewise be either male or female. The crime is
committed not only if X performs the act himself, when he inserts his own penis
into the vagina or anus of an animal, but also where he causes another person Y
to do so, as where he coerces Y to do so.
RAPE
Section 3 of the Criminal Law(sexual
offences and related matters) Amendment Act 32 of 2007 provides that any person
(A) who unlawfully and intentionally commits an act of sexual penetration with
a complainant (B), without the consent of B, is guilty of the offence of rape.
ELEMENTS
•Unlawfulness
•Intent
•Sexual
penetration
•Of
the complainant/without the consent of the latter person
Unlawfulness: the
crime can be committed by male or female as S3 provides that any natural person
may be the perpetrator of the crime. Proof of compulsion may exclude the
unlawfulness of the conduct. The only other defence that will exclude
unlawfulness is consent. The term ‘consent’ means voluntary or uncoerced
agreement.
S1(3) relate to circumstances in which
the complainant submits as a result of the use of force, intimidation, or
threats of harm against the complainant, another person, the property of the
complainant or another person. The provisions of this section reflect the ratio
from the case of R v Swiggerlaar.
However the statutory approach goes well beyond the scope of common law.
•S1(3)(a)
recognises any harm waged against any other person or property.
•S1(3)(b)relates
to cases where the legitimacy of the consent is violated by the abuse of power
or authority.
•S1(3)(c)
refers to cases, including misrepresentation by the accused, false pretences.
•S1(3)(d)
refers to circumstances in which the complainant lacks the capacity to
appreciate the nature of the sexual act at the time it took place. E.g.
complainant was asleep, unconscious , intoxicated, child below 12yrs, mentally
disabled.
•Intent: the intention of the accused must be to
unlawfully cause sexual penetration. The accused would lack intention if there
was a legitimate mistake in causing sexual penetration. Mistake being….
Legitimate consent to sexual penetration.
•Sexual penetration:
Section 1of the act defines ‘sexual penetration’ as including any act that
causes penetration to any extent whatsoever by:
a)The genital organs of one person into or
beyond the genital organs, anus or mouth of another person;
b)Any other part of body of one person or
any object including any part of the body of an animal, into or beyond the
genital organs or anus of another person; or
c)The genital organs of an animal, into or
beyond the mouth of another person.
A significant feature of the definition
of sexual penetration is that it relates to an act that ‘causes penetration’.
This is significant because it does not restrict the gender of the accused.
This means that a woman may be held liable for rape if she causes the
penetration of her genital organs by the genital organs of a male victim.
Similarly, a woman may be held liable for
rape if she causes the penetrating of another woman’s genital organs by using
any other part of her body or any object.
(page 358-362 snyman)
•Complainant: meaning
the alleged victim (any person) of the sexual offence. This is in terms of S1.
Please
note: it is
not a valid defence for an accused person to contend that a marital or other
relationship exists or existed between him or her and the complainant. It is
therefore, perfectly possible for a husband to rape his own wife.
sentencing
•After
the constitutional court in Makwanyane 1995 2 SACR 1 (CC) the death sentence
was no longer a competent sentence to be imposed upon a conviction of rape.
•Page368…
imprisonment for life may sometimes
be imposed ( under
the following circumstances)
•Page
369 other minimum sentences to be applied
COMPELLED
RAPE
S4 definition: any person (‘A’) who
unlawfully and intentionally compels a third person (‘C’) without the consent
of C, to commit an act of sexual penetration with the complainant (B), is
guilty of the offence of compelled rape.
ELEMENTS:
Unlawfulness, intent, compelling a third person, sexual penetration, the
complainant
(refer
to prescribed text for more info on the elements) lets look at a typical example of
same on pg 370 snyman
SEXUAL
ASSAULT
S5 provides that:
1.A person (A) who unlawfully and
intentionally sexually violates a complainant (B), without the consent of B, is
guilty of the offence of sexual assault.
2.A person (A) who unlawfully and
intentionally inspires the belief in a complainant (B) that B will be sexually
violated, is guilty of the offence of sexual assault.
ELEMENTS AS DEFINED IN S5(1) unlawfulness,
intent, an act of sexual violation, the complainant
ELEMENTS S5(2) unlawfulness,
intent, inspiring a belief, an act of sexual violation, the complainant
What is sexual violation?
•It
refers to cases that do not involve penetration. The statutory definition of sexual
violation includes (in-) direct contact between the genital organs (or anus of
another person or female breasts) and any other object or part of the body of
another person.
•Essentially
‘sexual violation’ refers to prohibited forms of sexual conduct that do not
amount to ‘sexual penetration’.
•It
also includes (in-) direct contact between the mouth of a person and:
1)The mouth of another person
2)Any object resembling the genital
organs(or anus of another person or a female’s breasts)
3)Any part of another person’s body that
can be used for sexual penetration, stimulation or arousal
4)The mouth of the complainant and the
genital organs (or anus) of an animal without causing sexual penetration
•Sexual
violation also includes the masturbation of one person by another person, or
the insertion of any object resembling or representing the genital organs of a
person or animal into or beyond the mouth of another.
COMPELLED SEXUAL ASSAULT
•S6
provides that: a
person (A) who unlawfully and intentionally compels a third person (C), without
the consent of C, to commit an act of sexual violation with s complainant B
without the consent of B is guilty of the offence of compelled sexual assault.
•ELEMENTS: unlawfulness, intent, compelling a third
person, sexual violation, the complainant.
•Compelling a third person: refers
to a person other than the accused or complainant. The conduct of the third
person must meet the requirements for justification of necessity as proof that
the third person was acting out of compulsion. Thus the accused must have been
threatening a worthy legal interest (life, bodily interest and
property).further the conduct of the third person must have been necessary and
reasonable under the circumstances.
COMPELLED SELF-SEXUAL ASSAULT
Read S7 (a), (b) and (c) for the
definition!
Elements
•Unlawfulness
•Intent
•The
complainant
•Compelling
the complainant
•Engaging
in conduct set out in Section 7
This
basically involves 2 parties X the perpetrator and Y the victim. X
compels Y to do or perform the ‘indecent’ act upon Y herself or himself.
•Unlawfulness: this crime can be committed by male or
female. As S7 provides that any natural person can be a perpetrator of the
crime. consent is defined by the provisions of section 1(2).
Consent for the statutory crime of compelled sexual assault, is absent in the
context of the circumstances identified in section 1(3) of the Act. The
contents of subsection S(2) and(3) of
section 1 have already been discussed under the elements of unlawfulness in the
crime of Rape.
•Intent: the intention of the accused must be to
unlawfully compel the complainant to engage in a conduct set out in S7 of Act
32 of 2007. the state bears the onus of proving that the accused had actual or
legal intention to perpetrate the conduct. The state must actually prove that
accused intended to compel the complainant to perform an act listed in S7,
knowing or foreseeing that the complainant had not legitimately consented
and yet carried out regulations.
•Complainant: already
discussed under the corresponding elements of rape
•Compelling the compainant:
the
conduct of the complainant must meet the requirements for the justification of
the necessity as proof that the complainant was acting out of compulsion. The
accused must have been threatening a worthy legal interest, posing a threat
that had either commenced or was imminent or posing a threat that was not due
to the complicit conduct of the complainant. Further note that the conduct of
the complainant must have been necessary and reasonable under the
circumstances.
•Engaging in a conduct set out in S7:
Section 7 prescribes conduct in three categories. The categories are not
mutually exclusive. The prohibited conduct includes conduct that involves
penetration of the genital organs or the anus of the person, but the prohibited
extends beyond acts of penetration. 1st
category
of prohibited conduct relates to cases where the complainant is compelled to
engage in conduct including sexual suggestive acts, self masturbation or any
sexual arousal/stimulation of a females breasts. 2nd category is a general prohibition against
any
conduct
that compels a complainant to engage in conduct that has the effect of sexually
arousing or degrading the complainant. The 3rd
category that compels the complainant to penetrate their own genital organs or
anus. There is no limitation to what the complainant may be forcer to use to
complete the penetration
COMPELLED WITNESSING OF SEXUAL OFFENCES
(ADULTS)
Section 8 provides that:
1)A
person (A) who unlawfully and intentionally, whether for the sexual
gratification of A or of the third person (C) or not, compels or causes the
complainant 18 years or older (B) without the consent of B, to be in the
presence of or watch A or C while he, she or they commit a sexual offence, is
guilty of the offence of compelling or causing a person 18yrs or older to
witness a sexual offence.
2)A
person (A) who unlawfully and intentionally, whether for the sexual
gratification of A or of a third person (C) or not, compels or causes a
complainant 18yrs or older (B) without the consent of B, to be in the presence
of watch-
–
A
while he or she engages in a sexual act with C or another person D or
–C
while he or she engages in a sexual act with D is guilty of the offence of
compelling or causing a person 18 years or older to witness a sexual act.
3) A person (A) who unlawfully and
intentionally, whether for the sexual gratification of A or of a third person
(C) or not, compels or causes a complainant 18yrs or older (B), without the
consent of B, to be in the presence of A or C while he or She engages in an act
of self masturbation, is guilty of the offence of compelling or causing a
person 18yrs or older to witness self-masturbation.
Elements
•Unlawfulness
•Intent
•The
complainant
•Compelling
a complainant 18yrs of age or older
•Being
in the presence of, or watching self masturbation or sexual offence/act
FLASHING
•S9
provides that: A person (A) who unlawfully and intentionally, whether for the
sexual gratification of A or of a third person (C) or not, exposes or displays
or causes the exposure or display of the genital organs, anus or female breasts
of A or C to a complainant 18yrs or older (B) without the consent of B, is
guilty of the offence of exposing or displaying or causing the exposure or
display of genital organs, anus or female breasts to a person 18yrs or older.
Elements
•Unlawfulness
•Intent
•The
complainant
•Exposure
or displaying of a designated body part
•Unlawfulness: the
conduct of the accused must have been necessary and reasonable under the
circumstances. The accused would escape liability if the complainant consented
to the conduct of the accused. further the location of the exposure may also
exclude the unlawfulness of the display. E.g. topless sunbathing may be lawful
at the beach. Also it may not be unlawful to witness at functions such as a
traditional Zulu ‘reed dance’ to be exposed to the bare breasts of the maidens.
•Intent:
must
be to unlawfully expose a designated body part to the complainant. The state
bears the onus of proving that the accused had actual or legal intention to
perpetrate the conduct. The state must prove that the accused intended to
expose a designated body part to the complainant knowingly or foreseeing that
the complainant had not legitimately consented and yet carried on regardless
•Complainant: as
explained in the rape element only that here complainant must be 18yrs or older
•Exposure or display of a designated body
part: the
conduct of the accused may only be punished for violating the provisions of S9
where he was responsible for exposing or displaying the genital organs, anus or
female breasts of a person other than the complainant, to the complainant.
General comment: there
is a overlap between a crime of crimen iniuria and S9 of Act 32 of 2007. please note crimen iniuria also
punishes acts of indecent exposure
EXPOSING A CHILD PORNOGRAPHY
•S10
provides that: A person (A) who unlawfully and intentionally, whether for the
sexual gratification of a third person (C) or not, exposes or displays or
causes the exposure or display of a child pornography to a complainant 18yrs or
older (B), with or without the consent of B, is guilty of the offence of
exposing or displaying or causing the exposure or display of child pornography
to a person 18 years or older.
Elements: unlawfulness,
intent, the complainant, exposure or display of child pornography
Snyman: X commits a crime if he or she unlawfully
and intentionally exposes or displays child pornography to Y. Y must be 18years
or older. If Y is younger than 18, a different section of the Act will apply
namely S19 is contravened.
•X
commits a crime not only if he or she plays pornography himself or herself, but also if he or she causes
another person to perform the displaying. The crime is committed irrespective
of whether Y consents to the displaying or not.
•General
comments: this crime criminalises the non-consensual exposure or display of
child pornography. It does not criminalise the conduct where a person is a
consenting viewer. This does not make sense, because the accused would be
guilty of being in possession of the offensive material and liable in terms of
S27 of the Films and Publications Act 65 of 1996. perhaps the consenting viewer
should be charged as an accomplice to the crime.
ENGAGING
SEXUAL SERVICES “FOR REWARD”(PROSTITUTION)
•It
may be called ‘sex for reward’
•Both
parties consent to the act.
•Prostitution
is mankind’s oldest profession.
Section 11 provides that: A person ‘A’
who unlawfully and intentionally engages the services of a person 18yrs or
older ‘B’ for financial or other reward, favour or compensation to B or to a
third person ‘C’-
a)For the purpose of engaging in a sexual
act with B irrespective of whether the sexual act is committed or not
b)By committing a sexual act with B is
guilty of the offence of engaging the sexual services of a person 18 years or
older
•Unlawfulness
•Intention
•Engaging
the services of a person 18years or older
•A
benefit to any person
•The
purpose of engaging in a sexual act or committing a sexual act with the person
whose services were engaged
General comments: the accused would be
liable for violating the prohibition in S11 regardless whether the sexual act
occurs or not. It seems redundant to criminalise the conduct of the accused
again if the act does not actually occur. That fact might be relevant for
sentencing.
The fact that any benefit in any form may
be sufficient to justify liability should be cause for concern. The
constitutional court has already declared that the crime can only be justified
in the context of commercial sex work
STATUTORY
RAPE
•S15
provides as follows: A person ‘A’ who commits an act of sexual penetration with a child ‘B’
is, despite the consent of B to the commission of such an act is guilty of the
offence of having committed an act of consensual sexual penetration with a
child.
•Elements: unlawfulness, fault, sexual penetration,
the child
•The
child…. A person under the age of 18 years; or
•With
reference to S15 and 16 a person 12 years or older but under the age of 16years
Statutory
sexual assault
A person ‘A’ who commits an act of sexual
violation with a child ‘B’, despite the consent of B to the commission of such
an act of the offence of having committed an act of consensual sexual violation
with a child
Elements: unlawfulness,
fault, sexual violation, the child
Sexual
exploitation of children
•S17
identifies a number of prohibited forms of exploitation. Subsection 1 of S17
prohibits engaging a child’s services for a benefit to any person for the
purpose of engaging in a sexual act or committing a sexual act with the child
whose services were engaged.
•Subs
2 prohibits persons from offering the services of a child complainant to
another person for financial or other reward, favour or compensation to
any person for the purpose of committing a sexual act between the child and
another person etc
•Elements unlawfulness, intention, the child, a
sexual act, exploitation
•General
comments: this crime has potential to attract controversy when it comes to
cultural and religious practices that arrange marriages for children younger
than 16yrs
Other crimes are self explanatory. Please
read them in your books as they are defined in the Act!
•Sexual
grooming of children S18 (1) and (2) all
•Exposure
of children to pornography S19
•Using
a child or benefiting from child pornography S20
•Compelled
witnessing of sexual offences(children)
•Flashing
to children
•Sexual
exploitation of mentally disturbed persons
SEXUAL
ACTS WITH A CORPSE
Section 14 provides as follows, a person
who unlawfully and intentionally commits a sexual act with a human corpse is
guilty of the offence of committing a sexual act with a corpse.
Elements: unlawfulness,
intention, a sexual act, a sexual act with a human corpse
•Pleas
note sexual act means: an act of sexual penetration or an act of sexual
violation. In the context of sexual penetration involving a corpse, the crime
could only occur where the conduct of the accused causes any part of a corpse
to penetrate the genital organs or anus of the accused.
•None
of the other forms of sexual penetration will qualify, because a corpse does
not qualify as a person in South African law. Kissing a corpse on the lips
would not fall within the definition of sexual violation because the mouth of a
corpse would not qualify as the mouth of another person
•General
comments: the state has no interest worth protecting through this crime. It is
purely amorality crime.
No comments:
Post a Comment