X commits murder when he unlawfully and
intentionally causes the death of Y, another human being.
causing death: X
must cause the death of Y. although
suicide is not a crime, if X assist Y to commit suicide, X may be convicted of
murder where it can be proved that X had unlawfully caused Y’s death in
accordance with the requirements of causation.
Thus where X agrees to help Y to commit
suicide, X may be convicted of murder, despite the final act of committing
suicide being carried out by Y. the legal consequences of so called ‘assistance
suicide’ and ‘euthanasia’(distinct but related) will be discussed in more
detail below.
In determining criminal liability, there
is a factual inquiry followed by a decision on legal liability. Where X
deliberately inflicts an intrinsically fatal wound, it is irrelevant whether
others failed to intervene to save the deceased. Such failure does not diminish
the legal culpability of X.
S v Thembani 2007
Causing death of another person:
X
must kill a living human being. For a crime of murder the meaning of a ‘living
human being’ is obviously paramount. This is a person who is born alive and who
is still alive when fatal conduct occurs. This question of fact is determined
on the basis of medico-legal evidence. See S v Ndlovu 1984
Unlawfulness: the
killing must be unlawful intention
intention: intention
(dolus) is
necessary for the crime of murder. Motive is irrelevant. Negligence is
insufficient for a conviction of murder.
While it may be difficult to lead direct
evidence as to the subjective state of mind of the accused at the time of the
assault, this may be established by drawing inference from circumstances of the
assault, the nature of the weapon used and the extent of the injuries
inflicted. This is not a piecemeal exercise. A holistic approach is required
when attempting to establish the subjective state of mind of the accused.
No comments:
Post a Comment