Friday, 23 September 2016


CRIMES AGAINST THE STATE AND THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE



•High Treason: a person commits high treason if owing allegiance to the republic of South Africa. She/he unlawfully engages in conduct within or outside the Republic with the intension of:


a)Overthrowing the government of the Republic;


b)Coercing the government by violence into any action or inaction.


c)Violating, threatening or endangering the existence, independence or security of the Republic; or


d)Changing the constitutional structure of the Republic.
ELEMENTS OF THE CRIME




a)The perpetrator must owe allegiance to the Republic


Meaning of allegiance:- “loyalty or commitment to a superior or to a group or cause”





Please note:  only persons owing allegiance to the republic can commit high treason. The category of persons owing allegiance is wider than the category of people who are citizens. therefore people who owe allegiance include:


•Citizens of the Republic


•People who have sworn an oath of allegiance to South Africa


•People who are domiciled in South Africa


•People who are resident in South Africa




Foreign diplomats who are stationed in South Africa (residing here) obviously do not owe allegiance to South Africa.
…ELEMENTS




Conduct/act of high treason


oRole of intention in determining whether there is a treasonable act, the hallmark of high treason is not a certain type of act but the hostile intent with which an act is committed. Any act committed however innocent it may seem can be viewed objectively and may constitute high treason if it constituted with the necessary hostile intent. This may be illustrated as per page311


oCommitting high treason by omission, this refers to every person who owes allegiance to the state and hears or becomes aware of the fact that high treason is being committed or that there is plan to do so, has a duty to report such to the authorities soonest. Failure to do so constitutes high treason.


oActs of treason in time of war and of peace, this is by assisting the enemy by fighting for it against the Republic or against one of its enemies. Furnishing information, committing acts of sabotage etc. Taking part in or instigating an armed revolt or rebellion against the Republic, plotting the overthrow of government, attacking of police station, concealing quantities of weapons in a certain place for a later use by the people wishing to overthrow the government.


Please note: the act of high treason may be committed either within or outside of the territory of the Republic of South Africa.

Unlawfulness this element of crime prevents a member of an opposition party, who strives for change of government or of the constitution in a lawful, constitutional way, from committing high treason.





d) Intention the intention which must company the act can be described as the definitive element of high treason. It is known as hostile, therefore X acts with hostile intent if she intends to overthrow the government unlawfully.



A fair interpretation of the relevant authorities is that hostile intent comprises the following, namely an intention (unlawfully) (a) to overthrow the government of the Republic; (b) to coerce the government by violence into any action or inaction; (c) to violate, threaten or endanger the existence, independence or security of the Republic; or (d) to change the constitutional structure of the Republic.


•Please note all acts of high treason are essentially mere attempts to destroy the existence, independence  or safety of the state. The state doesn’t need to be actually overthrown before high treason is committed.


•The Boeremag case, also look at Sec 35 of the constitution 1996.


•S v Banda and others1989
SUMMARY




•Treason is the betrayal of the allegiance that a person owes to a country by unlawfully attempting to overthrow or coerce the government of that country. Note that for a crime to be treason, there must be a “hostile” intent against the state, although it may be absent in the cases of public violence and sedition. Hostile intent has been described as intent to treat the state as an enemy, no motive needs to be proved in cases of treason.


•Hostile intent is said to be present when a person should foresee that the consequences of his or her actions might be to overthrow or coerce the State, but proceeds with these actions nevertheless.
SEDITION




What is Sedition?


“conduct or speech inciting people to rebel against the authority of a state”


it is taking part in a concourse of people violently or by threats of violence challenging or defying or resisting the authority of the state of the Republic of South Africa or causing such a concourse. It is crime that is not aimed at the individual but at the authority of the state.





•Elements of the crime: (a) taking part in a concourse of people (b) accompanied by violence or threats (c) challenging the authority of the state (d) unlawfulness (e) intention

The difference between Sedition and other crimes against the State areas follows:


•For high treason there must be a  hostile intent whereas for Sedition only intention to resist or challenge the authority of the State is required.


•Sedition can only be committed by a number (2 or more)of persons acting together unlike treason which can be committed by one person acting alone.


•For Sedition, no allegiance to the Republic is required.


•


Please note that Sedition differs from public violence in that it is aimed at authority of the State, whereas public violence is aimed at public peace and tranquillity
Case law




•State v Twala 1979 3 SA 864 (T)869 F-G


These were 11 members of Soweto Students Representatives Council who were convicted and sentenced to imprisonment.


•S v Zwane (3) 1989 3 SA 253 (w) 261E-F
PUBLIC VIOLENCE




Public violence consist in the unlawful and intentional commission by a number of people of an act or acts which assume serious dimensions and which are intended forcibly to disturb public peace and tranquillity or to invade the rights of others.


•Elements: (a) an act (b) by a number of people (c) which assumes serious proportions (d) which is unlawful and (e) intentional/intention to disturb the public peace and order by violent means or to infringe the rights of others.


•Interests protected here are public peace and security


•Public peace and tranquillity must be disturbed by a number of people acting in concert (with a common purpose)


•Please note S17 of the constitution





Examples: violent mob or forcible coercion by strikers of other workers
CRIMES AGAINST THE ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE




CONTEMPT OF COURT


In South African law,  two basic forms of contempt of court are criminalised


1.Contempt of court in facie curiae (that is contempt in the court-literally-in the face of the court)


2.Contempt of court ex facie curiae (conduct outside the courtroom)


The underlying rationale for the crime of contempt is to protect the dignity and institution of courts and the Administration of Justice. If the dignity and structure of courts are not respected, the justice system will not be able to function and in the long run it will collapse.
Contempt of court in facie curiae






It is committed when a person who is inside the court insults the presiding judicial officer (Judge or Magistrate) or otherwise misbehaves in a manner calculated to violate the dignity of the court or the judicial officer while the court is engaged in its proceedings.
The accused must have the necessary intention to insult or misbehave (clark 1958 (3) SA 394 (A)

S v Lewis 2007




•In this case the appellants cell phone rang in court and he answered it on his way out of court. Upon conviction, he was sentenced to 1 (one) month’s imprisonment. The Supreme court of Appeal, however, held that the Accused did not have the intent to disrupt court proceedings.


The power of the court to act against the accused is somehow controversial in that the presiding officer can act against the accused without having to wait for the accused to be investigated and the prosecuted for this crime by the prosecutor.

•In other words the presiding officer is the investigator, prosecutor and judge for purposes of this crime. S 108 of the magistrates act!


•Now since the prising officer in matters of contempt of court in facie curiae are both “prosecutors and judges” care should be taken to strike a balance between the need to protect the dignity of the court on the one hand, and the rights of the accused on the other.


•S v Mitchell 2011 (2) SACR 182 (ECP) In this case the accused swore the prosecutor. This happened while the accused was having his finger prints taken in court. The magistrate intervened and told the accused to stop and apologise . The accused refused. And dared the magistrate to punish him….. He was convicted to 6 months impr.


•On appeal the conviction was confirmed but sentenced was reduced!


IMPORTANT TO NOTE: that since the presiding officer is both prosecutor and judge in cases of contempt of court in facie curiae, the accused must be given the opportunity to explain to the presiding officer why he should not be convicted of contempt.
Contempt of court ex facie curiae




The forms of contempt of court ex facie curiae are normally divided into two groups:


1.Conduct that refers to pending cases


2.Conduct that does not refer to pending cases





Both forms of contempt can only be committed intentionally. However if the accused is a newspaper editor who is charged with contempt of court ex facie curiae for the publication of commentary or report concerning a pending case (in other words a violation of the sub judice rule), negligence will be enough for a conviction.

This form of contempt is often described as a violation of the so-called sub judice rule. This means that no one should publish anything about a pending case or a comment on case where the publication or commentary is potentially prejudicial to the outcome of the case.


Of course, newspapers report about pending cases all the time, but the tone and aim of the reporting must be factual, rather than a form of comment which would be prejudicial. Note that this is in conflict with S16 (1) of the 96 constitution.


Remember we need to protect the dignity and integrity of the legal process and also the rights of the accused which are to be protected by the court.
Interference with witness or the presiding officer




•It is a crime to improperly influence or attempt to influence a judge, magistrate, an assessor, witnesses, witnesses, complainant e.t.c


•Yes it does overlap with the crime of corruption.
Failure to appear in court


•If a person is summoned to appear in court but fails to do so intentionally and for no good reason. That individual will be prosecuted for contempt of court (ex facie curiae)





Scandalising the court S v Mamabolo 2001


Please make time to read on this. It will be discussed on the next occasion. Tell me your views based on what you have read!
elements




(a) (i) violation of the dignity


     (ii) the publication of information or commentary concerning   a pending judicial proceeding


(b) the administration of justice by the courts


(c) unlawfulness and


(d) intention
PERJURY AND RELATED CRIMES




Making a false statement under oath or affirmation in the course of a judicial proceeding is a crime under South African common law. The common law is supplemented by a statutory crime, namely making conflicting statements under different oaths (contravention of S319 (3) Act 56 of 1955). It is also a crime to make a false statement in an affidavit.





The rationale for the criminalisation of these offences is that witnesses should always tell the truth and nothing but the truth in courts or in affidavits. Without this the system will not be able to function effectively and with integrity.


Elements (a) making of a declaration (b) which is false (c) under oath or in a form equivalent to an oath (d) in the course of judicial proceeding (e) unlawfulness (f) intention
Common law perjury




This crime consists in the unlawful and international making of a false statement in the course of a judicial proceeding by a person who has taken the oath or made an affirmation before, or who has been admonition by, somebody competent to administer or accept the oath.


•False statements: means verbal or in writing in a form of an affidavit. Although the point has not been authoritavely decided in South Africa, it seems that the statement must be ‘objectively false’.


This means that a witness who intends(subjectively) to tell lie in court, but the statement in actual fact turns out to be true, commits not perjury but a crime of attempted perjury, or defeating or obstructing the course of justice.


•The state does not need to prove that the false statement is material to any issue to be decided by court.


•The case of perjury can only be committed in the course of a judicial proceeding (criminal or civil). Note that affidavits made to the police in  the context of an investigation do not qualify as ‘statements made in the course of judicial proceedings’


•Oath, affirmation or admonition: this requirement implies that any statements by a legal representative in court, as part of legal argument (in other words not testimony under oath)will be excluded from the ambit of the common-law crime perjury. It is important to note that witnesses must be sworn in, or the affirmation must be accepted by a court official who is competent.


•Intention: the accused must know (or at least foresee) the possibility that his statement maybe false. Thus dolus eventualis will be sufficient. It is also necessary to show that the accused knew that he was under oath(affirmation or admonition), and the relevant statement was made in the course of judicial proceedings.
MAKING CONFLICTING STATEMENTS UNDER DIFFERENT OATHS




•This kind of crime is in contravention of S 319 (3) of 1995 which provides: if a person ahs made any statement on oath whether orally or in writing, and he there after on another oath makes another statement as aforesaid, which is in conflict with such first- mentioned statements, he shall be guilty of an offence and may on a charge alleging that he made the two conflicting statements and upon proof of those two statements and without proof as to which of the said statements was false, be convicted of such offences and punished with the penalties prescribed by law for the crime of perjury, unless it is proved that when he made each statement he believed it to be true.


•unlike common law perjury, this statutory form of perjury does not require that the statements be made in the course of a judicial proceedings.

What state has to prove: is that the accused on two occasions made two conflicting statements under oath and that that the statements conflict each other. Mohamed 1951 1 SA 439 and


Mofokeng 1957 2 SA 162 (o)









No comments:

Post a Comment